Colgate Total Toothpaste Incident: Three Questions about the Quality and Safety of Triclosan

Source: Release time:2024-03-04 09:44:35 Browse: 305

"What kind of toothpaste is safe to use?" Recently, Bloomberg revealed that Colgate Total toothpaste contains triclosan, a substance that is alleged to cause fetal malformations and even cancer. Once this news broke, it attracted widespread attention across society, and many netizens raised the above question in their comments.

 

TheQuestioning of triclosan in Colgate toothpaste has been heard in 2005 and 2011. The reappearance of this kind of doubt in the newspapers has once again touched the sensitive nerves of the public.

 

Looking at the online public opinion on this incident, it can be roughly divided into four categories. In the first type of public opinion, netizens said they would no longer use Colgate toothpaste. In the second type of public opinion, netizens questioned why this old news was being rehashed and expressed their disdain for paying attention to this incident. In the third type of public opinion, netizens did not randomly take sides but showed rational thinking. Some netizens believed that "this is an old brand, and we should investigate it thoroughly", and "talking about toxicity without considering the dosage is playing tricks".

 

More netizens belong to the fourth type of public opinion, raising questions about the safety of triclosan and calling on relevant departments to provide authoritative answers. "We cannot confirm the conclusion made by a single scientist, and we cannot accept the logic that products sold in Western countries like the United States and Europe for many years are necessarily safe. China's food and drug administration department should have its own inspection conclusion." One netizen commented.

 

So, has Colgate sold or is it still selling toothpaste containing triclosan? Is triclosan really carcinogenic as reported? Are there national standards for strict regulation? These have all become unavoidable questions.

 

Question 1: Is the Involved Product Still on Sale?

During the interview, our reporter found that Colgate responded to this incident with two statements. A statement in September 2011 showed that the triclosan-containing Colgate Total Antibacterial Toothpaste once had a very small market share in China, and it stopped production in China at the beginning of that year due to commercial operation considerations. A statement issued on August 12, 2014, stated that based on commercial considerations, the company has not sold Colgate Total toothpaste in the Chinese mainland market.

 

The statement also explained that more than 70 clinical studies involving over 10,000 patients, as well as the scientific reviews by regulatory agencies such as the United States and the European Union that Colgate Total toothpaste has passed in the past 20 years, have all confirmed the safety and effectiveness of Colgate Total toothpaste.

 

This answer seems to have failed to dispel the doubts of the public and relevant institutions. It is reported that all Colgate toothpaste with the words "Total" or "Full Effect" are involved products. The former is sold in Hong Kong, and the latter was once sold on the Chinese mainland. The reporter's search found that this toothpaste on Amazon is out of stock, while it is still sold on Taobao, mostly being Colgate Total toothpaste purchased on behalf of others from Hong Kong, and there are sales in the past 30 days. This means that some domestic consumers are still using this toothpaste recently.

 

After the media reports, the Hong Kong Customs has solicited the opinion of the Hong Kong Department of Health on this issue and plans to conduct an investigation on the relevant reports. Currently, this toothpaste has been taken off the shelves in Hong Kong.

 

Triclosan, as a broad-spectrum antibacterial agent, is generally added to daily chemical products such as toothpaste. Media reports have stated that a doctor from the FDA (Food and Drug Administration of the United States) said that at least 2000 different soap products contain triclosan.

 

Some experts said that the application of triclosan in China is becoming more and more widespread. Before 2000, the usage amount of triclosan in China was only a few tons, and its source mainly relied on imports. After 2010, the annual output of triclosan in China reached hundreds of tons. The reporter searched for triclosan on Alibaba's wholesale website and found 281 related products, with the price of 1 kilogram ranging from 100 to more than 200 yuan.

 

Question 2: Is the 0.3% Limit Standard Reliable?

It is understood that in China's current standards, triclosan is allowed to be added to toothpaste raw materials, but there are limit indicators. The National Standard "Specifications for Toothpaste Raw Materials" (GB22115-2008) clearly stipulates that the limit value of triclosan is 0.3%, and it is pointed out that this kind of preservative can also be added to toothpaste for other purposes, but the use concentration should meet the same limit.

 

Xiang Jianqiang, Secretary General of the China Oral Cleaning and Care Products Industry Association, told the reporter that whether in the European Union, the United States, or China, triclosan is a preservative with a limited usage, allowed to be added to toothpaste, and the current limit standards in various countries are consistent. "It is safe if it does not exceed 0.3%."

 

So, what is the scientific basis for the 0.3% limit requirement in the European Union? Does it affect human health? Xiang Jianqiang pointed out that the EU's prohibition and restriction of various raw materials are generally based on the safety evaluation of the raw materials, that is, safety data. The safety data is made by the SCCS (Scientific Committee on Consumer Safety of the European Union), an official safety evaluation institution in the EU. The SCCS's conclusion on triclosan is that it is safe to add no more than 0.3% in toothpaste products.

 

China's "Hygiene Specifications for Cosmetics" issued in 2007 also has a limit of 0.3% for triclosan in the list of restricted preservatives in cosmetic ingredients. "Triclosan can be completely detected in China, and there are both detection standards and detection methods." According to Sun Dongfang, the main drafter of the National Standard "Specifications for Toothpaste Raw Materials", the 0.3% limit for triclosan is made by referring to relevant industry regulations in the EU and China, and there are specific methods to detect the content of triclosan in toothpaste.

 

It is reported that the Hong Kong Consumer Council recently sampled a total of 35 toothpaste products from 23 brands on the market. Among them, 3 ordinary toothpaste products including Colgate were detected to contain triclosan, a potentially carcinogenic preservative, but they all meet the upper limit of the standard.

 

Question 3: Can Triclosan Cause Cancer?

When many media reported on the triclosan incident, they all mentioned that toothpaste containing triclosan may cause fetal malformations or cancer, especially in the headlines.

 

There have been continuous disputes about the carcinogenicity of triclosan in recent years, especially in 2010. In June 2010, the FDA issued a report on triclosan, pointing out that experimental tests have confirmed that low-dose triclosan can cause gene mutations in bacteria, increase the probability of generating drug-resistant genes, and transmit drug resistance to other bacteria. However, when answering members of the U.S. House of Representatives Energy and Commerce Committee, the FDA said that it has not obtained sufficient safety data to recommend that consumers not use products containing triclosan.

 

In March 2011, the European Scientific Committee on Consumer Safety once again evaluated the safety of triclosan and issued a thick "Opinion on Triclosan", which recorded in detail the results of safety experiments in medical and toxicological aspects. The conclusion of the opinion is that using triclosan at a maximum concentration of 0.3% in toothpaste, hand sanitizer, body wash, and deodorant is considered safe. "There is currently no conclusive evidence to prove that triclosan causes fetal malformations or cancer." Xiang Jianqiang emphasized.

 

It is understood that from the perspective of raw materials, toothpaste industry testing institutions have sampled products for 20 consecutive years and have not found any unsafe factors. "The main function of triclosan is to sterilize and preserve, but it is not an additive that must be added. There are many other substances that can replace triclosan." "For example, some Chinese herbal toothpaste in China uses Chinese herbal medicines for antibacterial purposes." Xiang Jianqiang said.